Welcome guest, please Login or Register

   

Sura Fatiha - revealed in Mecca or Madina

Rank

Total Posts: 15

Joined 2011-05-15

PM

 


Some where I read that according to Ibn Abbas, Qataddah and Aul Aalia Sura Fatiha is a Meccan sura. (Reference not given)

According to Abu Hurrairah, Mujahid, Ata and Zahiri, it is a Madinan sura. (Reference not given)

Some are of the opinion that this Sura was revealed both in Mecca and Madina.(Mirza Bashiruddin Ahmad-1988- Translation in English- Holy Quran)

Qartabi while referring to Al-Saalbee opined that this sura was revealed twice, once in Mecca and then in Madina. To avoid repetition this sura is included in the Quran only once.

Please comment

Rank

Total Posts: 3

Joined 2017-06-13

PM

 

THANSK FOR THE SHARE